How Tenant Screening Reports Safeguard Your Rental Properties

Tenant screening reports are essential for landlords to select reliable tenants by providing detailed information on credit, criminal, and eviction histories. These reports ensure informed decisions, helping protect rental properties and maintain a positive tenant relationship.

Gemma Smith
Last Updated
May 20, 2024
How Tenant Screening Reports Safeguard Your Rental Properties

When managing rental property processes, selecting reliable and responsible tenants is paramount. That’s where comprehensive tenant screening services come into play. These services provide in-depth tenant screening reports, which include vital information such as credit and background checks, credit reports, criminal records, and rental history.

Property managers, real estate agents, and property owners heavily rely on this data-driven approach to make well-informed decisions about prospective tenants.

By thoroughly examining a tenant’s credit history, landlords can assess financial stability, including income verification and FICO score. Furthermore, conducting meticulous background checks, encompassing sex offender searches and evaluations of eviction history and criminal background, helps identify any red flags that may indicate potential issues down the line.

By leveraging reliable tenant screening solutions, property professionals can build their own database of great tenants, avoiding the pitfalls of horror stories involving property damage and lease disputes. Ultimately, it empowers them to make informed decisions, select the right tenant, and create a harmonious and secure rental environment.

What is a tenant screening report?

While many landlords conduct informal tenant screenings by meeting prospective renters and discussing their lifestyle or reasons for leaving their previous property, a formal tenant screening report delves deeper. A formal tenant screening report is generated using a tenant screening system that ensures all necessary checks are conducted thoroughly.

Typically, tenant screening reports include a comprehensive examination of a tenant’s credit history, eviction records, previous address history, and criminal background.

Additionally, these reports can cover employment history, previous rental history, and the verification of the applicant’s Social Security number. To access this sensitive information, landlords and credit agencies must obtain written, dated consent from prospective tenants through a rental application form.

This form should collect essential details such as the name, address, date of birth, and Social Security number of every adult named on the lease agreement.

An important aspect of conducting tenant screening is adhering to an unbiased approach in compliance with the Fair Housing Act. This federal law prohibits discrimination in housing-related activities based on race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status, or national origin.

Ensuring fair and equal treatment during the tenant screening process is not just a legal obligation but also a moral one, promoting diversity and inclusivity within rental properties.

The importance of tenant screening

Following the explanation of what a tenant screening report entails, it’s key to understand why thorough tenant screenings are indispensable for landlords and property managers. These screenings serve as a defense mechanism against potential risks and issues arising from leasing properties to unsuitable tenants, making it crucial to screen prospective tenants thoroughly.

  • Preventing financial loss: One of the primary risks of inadequate tenant screening is the heightened likelihood of rent defaults. By thoroughly examining a tenant’s financial history through credit checks, landlords can better gauge the applicant’s ability to fulfill rent obligations consistently.
  • Protecting property condition: Landlords may inadvertently rent to individuals who neglect the property or cause intentional damage without a detailed screening. Previous rental history and landlord references can offer insights into a tenant’s behavior and their likelihood of maintaining the property well.
  • Minimizing legal risks: Renting to individuals with a history of criminal activity or those prone to legal disputes can introduce unnecessary risks to the property and its community. Comprehensive background checks help mitigate these risks by ensuring prospective tenants have a clean legal slate.
  • Ensuring lease compliance: Proper screening aids in identifying tenants more likely to adhere to lease terms, reducing the incidence of violations such as unauthorized occupants or pets. This compliance is crucial for maintaining the integrity and smooth operation of the rental property.

How much does a tenant screening report cost?

Many landlords are wary of tenant screening reports to avoid unnecessary costs. However, the reality is that a thorough tenant screening process could help prevent future costs by saving you the trouble of an unreliable tenant. Moreover, many tenant screening services allow landlords to request that their applicants pay the screening fee. 

Typically, tenant screening report fees range from $25 to $75, depending on the company and the report's details. This range may also depend on your location and how local laws regulate tenant screening. 

Azibo provides landlords with a free portal for tenant applications with the option to add background checks that include credit, criminal, and eviction reports — and cost prospective tenants $39.99. That means you can use the same platform for rent collection, reviewing tenant applications, and filling vacancies. 

Components of a tenant screening report

Understanding the components of a tenant screening report is vital for landlords to comprehensively evaluate potential tenants and make informed decisions about whom to entrust with their property. This section breaks down the key elements typically included in these reports, highlighting how each contributes to a thorough assessment of an applicant's suitability for tenancy.

1. Current income

As a property owner, you want confirmation that your tenant has the means to pay their monthly rent. Checking recent pay stubs or tax returns can help you understand tenants' current income and whether they can afford your rent. 

Typically, landlords look for a monthly income of roughly three times the cost of rent. If a tenant doesn't provide a pay stub or official W-2 form, you might ask for another proof of income, including bank statements, brokerage statements, full credit reports, or additional records.

2. Credit report and score

Credit checks give landlords visibility into prospective tenants' credit scores, debts, and payment histories. Renters are usually expected to score between 600 and 650, depending on location, the property type, and the landlord's preferences.

Younger tenants, for example, may not have a credit score or a strong credit report or history. Others may be working to pay off debt and trying to improve their credit score to prove they are reliable tenants who can pay rent. You can tell tenants they can boost their credit score by reporting on-time rent payments through Azibo.

3. Employment history

Checking a prospective tenant's employment history is another way to determine whether they can reliably pay rent each month. Some landlords may even call their prospective tenant's current employer or ask for employment references to verify they have a job. 

That said, employers usually don't — or legally cannot — disclose more information about their tenant's employment beyond confirming they're employees. Keep the Fair Housing Act requirements top of mind when reviewing applications from younger or underprivileged tenants who may not have the same income level or work experience as others. 

4. Rental and eviction history

Reviewing a prospective tenant's rental or eviction history can give you a valuable glimpse into their past behavior. Eviction reports typically pull from public court records regarding failure to pay rent on time, warrants for eviction, and more.

Like credit bureaus, national agencies collect relevant information about tenants' rental histories in most states. 

5. References from previous landlords

Some landlords ask that tenants provide references from previous landlords. This can help you gauge whether a tenant paid on time in the past and left the property in good condition. 

While not everyone requires references, checking in with a previous landlord can be a great way to gain supplemental information about a prospective tenant and confirm whether they're a good fit for your property. 

6. Communication abilities and lifestyle

Communication is a crucial part of the rental process. Landlords and tenants should communicate their expectations upfront to confirm alignment and ensure they're a good fit for one another. For example, many landlords have rules surrounding pets, visitors, parties, and loud music — while tenants have expectations about what they should be able to do in their home. 

In other words, look out for specific requests in renter applications. If a prospective tenant is a musician, for example, they may want to be able to play their drums at all hours of the day or host band rehearsals at home. 

3 best practices for using tenant screening reports

Adopting best practices for using tenant screening reports is crucial for landlords to navigate the complexities of property management while ensuring fairness and legal compliance to screen tenants. Here are key strategies to effectively leverage these reports:

1. Legal compliance

It's paramount for landlords to familiarize themselves with and adhere to the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) and other applicable housing laws. This ensures the tenant screening process respects tenants' rights and avoids legal pitfalls.

Compliance involves obtaining explicit consent from applicants before conducting screenings and handling all obtained information responsibly.

2. Consistent screening criteria

To promote fairness and prevent accusations of discrimination, landlords should apply the same screening criteria to all applicants. This approach helps maintain a transparent and equitable process, ensuring all potential tenants are evaluated based on the same standards.

Having a standard procedure set up for this process helps prevent any unintentional discrimination.

3. Transparent communication

Clear, upfront communication with applicants about the screening criteria and decision-making process can greatly enhance the landlord-tenant relationship. When applicants understand what information will be evaluated and how decisions are made, it reduces potential misunderstandings and disputes.

Additionally, if a tenant is denied based on the screening report, providing a clear explanation and, when applicable, instructions for disputing inaccuracies in their report is not only a best practice but a legal requirement under the FCRA.

How does tenant screening work with Azibo?

Azibo's tenant screening services offer an efficient solution for landlords, seamlessly integrating into our property management platform. Landlords can easily create rental applications and initiate tenant background checks, with the screening costs passed on to the renters.

This approach ensures that the screening process is straightforward and financially transparent, allowing landlords to conduct thorough checks on multiple properties without incurring significant out-of-pocket expenses.

By centralizing tenant screening within Azibo's suite of property management tools, landlords are equipped to make well-informed decisions about prospective tenants, enhancing the efficiency of their rental operations while maintaining a cost-effective strategy.

Sign up for your free Azibo account today!

Using tenant screening services for a better tenancy

As we navigate the intricate pathways of property management, the role of comprehensive tenant screening reports cannot be overstated. These reports are more than just paperwork; they are the foundation for building a secure, harmonious community within your rental properties.

By meticulously evaluating prospective tenants, landlords can shield their investments from potential financial and legal pitfalls, ensure the maintenance of their property, and cultivate a positive living environment for all residents.

The strategic integration of tenant screening, especially through platforms like Azibo, simplifies this process and empowers landlords to make informed, unbiased decisions. In essence, effective tenant screening is not just about selecting the right tenant; it's about creating a legacy of trust, safety, and community in the real estate realm.

Embrace these best practices and watch as your rental properties thrive, fostering success and satisfaction for landlords and tenants alike.

Rental screening reports FAQs

What background check do most landlords use?

Most property owners commonly use background checks that include a tenant's credit report, criminal records, and rental history when evaluating prospective tenants.

What are considered red flags when conducting a tenant background search?

Red flags in screening a potential tenant include poor credit history, criminal records, eviction history, inconsistent income, negative references, false information on the application, high debt-to-income ratio, and an unwillingness to sign a lease.

What is "screening tenants"?

Screening tenants is the process property owners use to assess the suitability of prospective tenants for their rental properties. It involves evaluating an applicant's financial, rental, and personal history to determine their ability to pay rent on time and maintain the property properly.

Important Note: This post is for informational and educational purposes only. It should not be taken as legal, accounting, or tax advice, nor should it be used as a substitute for such services. Always consult your own legal, accounting, or tax counsel before taking any action based on this information.

Gemma Smith

With 7 years in property management, Gemma serves as a key content strategist at While excelling in writing, editing, and SEO, she also enhances Azibo's social media presence. Passionately, Gemma educates others to make informed real estate investment decisions in the ever-changing market.

Other related articles

Rental rundown background image
Rental rundown hero image

Whether you’re a property owner, renter, property manager, or real estate agent, gain valuable insights, advice, and updates by joining our newsletter.

Subscriber Identity

I am a

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.