Who Pays the Broker Fee When Renting? Costs, Explained

Rental broker fees can make or break your apartment hunt or investment strategy — here are the details both tenants and landlords need. This article explores these fees across different U.S. cities, offering strategies for both parties to potentially reduce costs. We also share how modern property management platforms help streamline rental processes and reduce operational burdens.

Nichole Stohler
Last Updated
July 5, 2024
Who Pays the Broker Fee When Renting? Costs, Explained

In some rental markets, you can't just hop on Apartments.com, click a few buttons, and easily find a new apartment. In very competitive areas where there is a limited supply of apartments available, brokers are a part of the rental process. Consider New York City, where the vacancy rates in 2023 were 1.4%, the lowest it's been in over 50 years.

Just like you'd use a real estate broker to help you buy a house, in these areas, you use the broker to help you with your apartment hunt. Broker fees cover services like property searches, coordinating viewings, and assisting with the leasing process.

So, if you're using the services of a broker, the question now is: who pays for their time? Is it the prospective tenant? Or is it the landlord or property management company? This article covers what you need to know about rental broker fees for renters hunting for apartments and landlords filling vacancies.

Understanding rental broker fees

Real estate brokers charge "finder's fees" for their services in helping tenants find rentals or landlords fill vacancies. These fees vary based on location, market conditions, and specific services provided, which may include:

  • Property search and viewing coordination.
  • Lease assistance and management.
  • Tenant background checks.
  • Handling initial rent and security deposit.

A broker's fee structure typically ranges from 10% to 15% of annual rent; however, some markets use flat fees instead of percentages.

Brokers usually charge these fees when the renter signs the lease. In competitive markets, some brokers might require a portion of the fee upfront as a retainer.

Why use a buyer's agent?

If you live in an area where finding an apartment is challenging, using a buyer's agent might be worthwhile. Having your own broker allows you to find rental units that meet your specific needs and potentially find listings not publicly advertised, helping you beat the competition and get the best deal possible.

Why use a landlord's agent?

For property owners, using a landlord's agent can reduce your work and make your property more of a passive investment. Reasons you might consider hiring a real estate agent and paying a broker fee are:

  • Market expertise: A rental broker has knowledge of the local rental market, including current rental rates, market trends, and the competitive landscape. This expertise helps in setting the right rental price and attracting suitable tenants.
  • Tenant screening: One of the broker's services is conducting tenant screenings, including background checks, credit reports, and rental history verification. This process helps you select reliable and responsible tenants, reducing the risk of future issues.
  • Marketing and advertising: A broker has access to various advertising channels and networks, so they can effectively market your property, reach a wider audience, and fill vacancies faster.
  • Lease management: The broker fee includes aspects of lease management, including verifying compliance with legal requirements and reducing landlords' administrative burden.
  • Time savings: Part of the reason you pay a broker fee is to offload tasks like property showings and screening so you can focus on other areas of your real estate business.

Rentals without broker fees

Some rental markets might have options for no-fee apartments. You can find these apartments through direct listings by private landlords, property management companies, or online platforms that connect landlords and tenants without a broker's involvement.

In competitive markets with low rental supply, finding a no-fee apartment can be challenging even with these methods. An effective alternative is to network with friends, family, or coworkers who might know of available apartments that match your criteria.

Broker fees in different markets

Broker's fee practices vary across different markets in the United States:

  • New York City: Broker fees range from 12% to 15% of the annual rent. Currently, the prospective tenant pays this fee, but city lawmakers are considering a bill that would require the landlord to pay it.
  • New Jersey: The broker fee is typically equivalent to one month's rent. Potential tenants pay the cost in competitive market areas like Hoboken and Jersey City.
  • Chicago: The common fee is equivalent to the first month's rent, but it's usually paid by the property management company or landlord.
  • Other areas: Many other regions don't have standard broker fees for rentals, especially outside major urban centers or a less competitive market.

Tips for lowering broker fees

Are broker fees negotiable? There's no hard and fast answer, but here are some strategies both landlords and tenants can use to see if the agent will reduce their brokerage fees.

For landlords

  • Negotiate: The real estate broker might be open to negotiation. Approach the conversation respectfully, explaining your budget constraints to see if they're willing to lower their fee.
  • Bundle services: If you're using the real estate broker for multiple services, such as finding tenants and managing the property, ask if they can offer a discounted rate for bundling these services together.
  • Multiple quotes: Contact several firms to compare their brokerage fees. Use the information from one broker as leverage to negotiate a lower fee with another.

For renters

  • Longer lease: Some brokers might be willing to reduce their fee if you agree to sign a longer lease, as it guarantees stability and reduces their need to find a new tenant soon.
  • Off-season: The demand for rentals can vary with the seasons. For example, no one wants to move in the middle of winter, so renting during these off-seasons might give you more bargaining power to lower the broker's fee.
  • Referrals: Some brokers offer referral discounts if you were referred by a previous client. See if anyone in your network can provide a referral.

Simplifying rentals for landlords and tenants

If you're a property manager or owner, one of the ways you can streamline operations is to use an integrated property management platform like Azibo. This all-in-one solution can help you manage your investments with the following offerings:

  • Online applications: Azibo allows prospective tenants to apply for rentals online, eliminating the need for physical paperwork and reducing the time spent managing applications.
  • Tenant screenings: The platform offers comprehensive tenant screening services, including background checks, credit reports, and rental history. By using these built-in tools, landlords can handle screening in-house to select the best renters.
  • Lease agreements: Azibo provides customizable, legally compliant, state-specific lease agreement templates with electronic signatures. This feature simplifies the lease creation and signing process.
  • Rent collection: Azibo facilitates secure online rent collection, allowing tenants to pay rent electronically. This helps provide timely payments and reduces the risk of errors.
  • Maintenance and messaging: The platform includes tools for managing maintenance requests and communicating with tenants. Landlords can quickly track and respond to maintenance issues, increasing tenant satisfaction.
  • Document storage: Azibo offers secure storage for all important rental documents. This makes accessing and managing details easy and reduces your administrative burden.

Rent broker fee

Broker fees are a reality in many competitive rental markets. They can greatly impact the cost of renting or leasing out a property. For tenants, understanding these fees might mean the difference between landing that perfect apartment or passing it up. For landlords, it could affect how quickly they fill vacancies and the quality of tenants they attract.

In areas where apartments are scarce and demand is high, broker fees are often part of the deal, but that doesn't mean you can't be smart about them. Knowing who typically pays, what services you're getting, and when you might be able to avoid them altogether can give you an edge.

The rental market is always changing, and what's standard practice today might shift tomorrow. So whether you're looking for a new place or trying to rent out your property, staying updated on broker fees is just good business.

Who pays the broker fee when renting? FAQs

Do tenants pay a broker fee in NJ?

In northern New Jersey, tenants typically pay the broker fee, usually one month's rent. This is more common in the East than in the West part of the state. Landlords may cover the fee as an incentive or pay the commission themselves, but this can result in higher rent.

What is a broker in rent?

A broker in rent is an intermediary who helps tenants find rental properties and landlords find tenants, often charging a fee for their services.

Do most NYC apartments have broker’s fees?

In NYC, many apartments have broker fees, but you might find some no-fee options using online listings or direct landlord contacts.

Important Note: This post is for informational and educational purposes only. It should not be taken as legal, accounting, or tax advice, nor should it be used as a substitute for such services. Always consult your own legal, accounting, or tax counsel before taking any action based on this information.

Nichole Stohler

Nichole co-founded Gateway Private Equity Group, with a history of investments in single-family and multi-family properties, and now a specialization in hotel real estate investments. She is also the creator of NicsGuide.com, a blog dedicated to real estate investing.

Other related articles

Rental rundown background image
Rental rundown hero image

Whether you’re a property owner, renter, property manager, or real estate agent, gain valuable insights, advice, and updates by joining our newsletter.

Subscriber Identity

I am a

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.