11 Valid Reasons to Deny a Rental Application

Explore valid reasons to deny a rental application, ensuring fairness and compliance with housing laws, and make informed rental decisions today.

Gemma Smith
Last Updated
September 25, 2023
11 Valid Reasons to Deny a Rental Application

Every landlord or property manager is searching for reliable and responsible tenants to maintain the integrity of their rental property and ensure a steady stream of rent. However, the tenant screening process can be a complex terrain to navigate. It's a careful act, balancing the protection of landlord rights while ensuring fairness to all prospective tenants. 

Understanding the legal reasons to deny a rental application becomes imperative. This knowledge streamlines the tenant selection process and safeguards landlords from potential legal disputes.

In this guide, we'll explore these valid reasons to deny a rental application, providing clear, actionable insights that move beyond the basics to cater to a more informed property manager. From evaluating the prospective tenant's credit report and income-to-rent ratio to considering their criminal history and previous evictions, we delve into the nitty-gritty of legal reasons to deny a prospective tenant's application.

So stay tuned whether you're a seasoned landlord well-versed in the tenant screening process or just starting in the rental business. We're shedding light on these vital factors in the rental application screening process, helping you find the right tenants for your property.

The importance of fair screening in rental applications

Effective and fair screening of rental applications is more than just a best practice — it's a legal necessity. While landlords have the right to select the best potential tenant for their property, ensuring that the screening process adheres to the guidelines established by the Fair Housing Act and any local anti-discrimination laws is crucial.

Fair screening allows for an objective assessment of each applicant based on factual information rather than personal prejudices or assumptions. This helps prevent unintentional bias and ensures that every applicant has an equal opportunity to secure housing. Furthermore, it preserves the landlord's reputation and decreases the risk of legal issues, as discrimination in the rental process can result in hefty penalties.

At the same time, an unbiased screening process supports diversity within rental properties, which can enrich the community and even enhance the appeal of your property to future tenants. By ensuring fairness in rental applications, landlords can foster positive relationships with tenants and protect their investments ethically and equitably.

It's not just about ticking regulatory boxes -- fair screening can contribute to a more positive, inclusive, and successful rental experience for everyone involved.

11 valid reasons to deny rental application for a prospective tenant

1. Insufficient income

This is one of the most straightforward reasons for denial. If the applicant's income isn't adequate to cover the rent, renting to them would come with significant risk. Many landlords look for tenants whose income is at least three times the monthly rent.

2. Unfavorable credit report and history

While one or two minor issues shouldn't be a cause for concern, a financial history full of significant unpaid debts, bankruptcies, or a low credit score can indicate financial irresponsibility.

3. Negative references

Past landlords, employers, and personal references can provide insights into the applicant's reliability, behavior, and history of paying rent on time.

4. Inconsistent or false information on the application

A tenant providing information that can't be verified or is found to be false can disqualify the candidate from approval.

5. Past evictions

If an applicant has been evicted from a previous property for legal reasons, especially for unpaid rent or causing significant property damage, they may not be a suitable candidate.

6. Criminal history

While you can't have a blanket policy against renting to people with criminal records due to Fair Housing guidelines, convictions related to property damage, violence, or other serious offenses can factor into your decision on a case-by-case basis.

7. Insufficient rental history

If an applicant doesn't have a rental history, assessing their reliability as a tenant might be more challenging. However, this shouldn't be the sole reason for denial, especially for younger tenants or those just starting out on their own.

8. Smoking or pet concerns

If the property has a no smoking or no pet policy and the applicant is a smoker or has pets, this could be grounds for denial.

9. Too many occupants

Overcrowding can be a legitimate concern, especially if it exceeds local regulations or could strain the property's facilities.

10. Poor interview or property visit

If the potential tenant displays behavior that might indicate they won't respect the property or its rules during the interview or property visit, it could be a valid reason for denial.

11. Incomplete application

If an applicant doesn’t provide all required documentation or leaves certain fields empty, especially after failing to complete it despite reminders, they may be deemed unreliable and be reasonably denied.

Navigating the Fair Housing Act in the rental application process

Once the core reasons for denying a rental application are clear, the reasons must then be framed within the Fair Housing Act (FHA) context. Instituted in 1968 and continually updated, the FHA is the bedrock for promoting equal housing opportunities in the U.S., laying out the boundaries for landlords and property managers.

What Does the FHA Advocate?

  • No room for discrimination: Fundamentally, the FHA prohibits discrimination in housing-related transactions based on race, color, religion, sex, disability, familial status, or national origin. When denying a rental application, none of these factors should influence the decision.
  • Transparent advertising: It's not only about how applications are processed -- even the advertising of the listing must be nondiscriminatory. Any inclination towards a particular group, even inadvertently, can potentially violate the FHA.
  • Provision for disabilities: The FHA emphasizes the importance of landlords accommodating tenants with disabilities. This may require making property modifications or adjustments in standard protocols to make housing accessible and comfortable for them.

Applying FHA to rental denials

When reviewing rental applications, landlords and property managers must make decisions consistent with the FHA's valid reasons for denial. For instance, while criminal history can be a reason for denial for an individual's specific case, criminal history cannot be an automatic disqualifier. This rule, like others, protects applicants from undue discrimination.

Moreover, state and local legislations might have additional protected categories, so keeping abreast of regional laws is equally important.

Do you have to tell rental applicants they've been denied?

Transparency and effective communication lie at the heart of a good tenant-landlord relationship. When a rental application is denied, it's not just about the ethical obligation to inform the applicant; there's often a legal mandate as well.

The legal aspect

The Federal Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) mandates that the applicant has the right to know if the denial of a rental application is based on any information found in their credit report. They must be provided with the following:

  1. A notice of the adverse action (in this case, the denial).
  2. The name, address, and phone number of the credit reporting agency that supplied the report.
  3. A statement indicating that the credit reporting agency didn't make the decision to deny their application and cannot provide specific reasons for the denial.
  4. Information on the applicant's right to dispute the accuracy or completeness of any information in the report.

Even if the denial isn't based on a bad credit report, certain states and municipalities have laws requiring landlords to provide a reason for denial, so be sure to research your local laws.

The ethical aspect

Beyond the legal requirements, informing applicants of a denial is an ethically responsible thing to do. It provides closure to the applicant, allowing them to understand areas of improvement or seek housing alternatives promptly.

How to communicate a denial

  • Be prompt: Notify the applicant once the decision is made, allowing them to move forward with other housing opportunities.
  • Be clear: If you're providing a reason, state it without ambiguity.
  • Be professional: Ensure the tone is respectful and empathetic. Avoid using jargon or overly technical terms.
  • Be prepared for feedback: Some applicants might seek clarification or challenge the denial. Be ready to engage in a constructive dialogue while adhering to legal guidelines.

Azibo: Your partner in effective tenant screening

After diving deep into the intricacies of the tenant selection process, the importance of adhering to the Fair Housing Act, and understanding the balance between landlord rights and fairness, it's evident that choosing the right tenant requires more than just gut instinct. It calls for a systematic, detailed, and comprehensive approach. This is where Azibo comes in.

Simplified Application Process: With our free online rental application, you can effortlessly collect the personal information of prospective tenants. This includes essentials like name, email, and phone number. Moreover, you can securely store sensitive details like birth dates and the desired move-in date.

Thorough history checks: Understanding a tenant's past can provide invaluable insights into their future behavior. Our history checks gather crucial details about the applicant's rental history, income, and employment. From their reasons for moving to their employment stability and monthly earnings, running a background check with Azibo ensures you have a holistic understanding of your applicant.

Comprehensive tenant screening: Possibly the most important step in the application process is screening. We offer a robust tenant screening service, allowing you to see the complete picture. This includes:

  • Full credit reports showing credit scores, outstanding debt, and more.
  • Nationwide criminal history checks include checks against OFAC terrorist watchlists, the most-wanted list, and sex offender registries.
  • Eviction records span all 50 states, helping you identify red flags before they become problematic.

The cherry on top? Tenant screening services are free for landlords. Applicants pay a one-time fee, ensuring that the process remains cost effective for property owners.

In the challenging landscape of rental applications and tenant screening, having a reliable partner can make all the difference. With Azibo, you'll always have the tools you need in your back pocket. Navigate the tenant selection process confidently, making informed decisions that benefit your property and provide you with peace of mind.

Making tenant screening simpler and more efficient

Choosing the right tenant is a delicate balance of ensuring fairness and protecting your investment as a landlord. Throughout this guide, we've underscored the significance of valid reasons to deny a rental application, always being mindful of the guidelines set by the Fair Housing Act.

However, the practical side of tenant screening can be time-consuming and daunting. This is where tools like Azibo can be of assistance. Azibo offers a straightforward process to gather tenant information, conduct essential background checks, and offer credit reports. Its streamlined system ensures that all the necessary information is accessible and organized.

Ultimately, every landlord or property manager aims for an efficient, fair, and lawful tenant selection process. By combining the knowledge shared in this guide with user-friendly tools like Azibo, the journey to finding the right tenant can be a little easier and more informed.

Deny rental application FAQs

What is the best way to reject a rental applicant?

The best way to reject a rental applicant is through a clear and professional communication process, typically in the form of an adverse action letter if the denial is based on information from their credit report. When denying rental applications, landlords and property managers should be transparent, citing valid reasons for the denial. 

It's also crucial to adhere to the Fair Credit Reporting Act and the Fair Housing Act to ensure you're not violating any federal laws or discriminating against any protected classes. If the denial is based on the credit score, provide details on how the applicant can access a free copy of their credit report to verify the information.

Which of the following is not a legitimate reason to reject someone as a tenant?

Without having a specific list provided, it's essential to understand that rejecting someone based on their race, religion, national origin, gender, familial status, disability, or sexual orientation is not a valid reason and can be seen as arbitrary discrimination. These categories are considered protected classes under the Fair Housing Act. 

Rejecting a prospective tenant based on their belonging to a protected class can lead to legal trouble for landlords and property managers. Additionally, rejecting an applicant due to their use of a service animal or participation in other subsidy programs would not be a legitimate reason. Always double check that the reasons for denial align with fair housing laws and other local laws.

Can you reject a rental application based on credit score?

Yes, a landlord or property manager can reject a rental application based on credit score. A low credit score can indicate potential financial risks, like the inability to pay rent consistently. However, if a rental applicant is rejected due to their credit report, the landlord must follow the Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) guidelines. This means providing an adverse action letter detailing the reasons for the denial and including the name and contact details of the credit reporting agency that supplied the report.

The applicant should also be informed of their right to a free copy of the report and the ability to dispute any inaccuracies. While credit score is a valid reason for denial, it should be applied uniformly across all prospective tenants to avoid any potential discrimination or violation of fair housing laws.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this article is intended for general informational purposes only and should not be considered legal advice. While every effort has been made to ensure accuracy and completeness, the author(s) and publisher do not guarantee that the information is free from errors or omissions. Landlords, property managers, and prospective tenants are advised to consult with a legal professional or familiarize themselves with their local laws and regulations before making any decisions based on the content of this article. Readers are responsible for their actions and any consequences that may arise from them.

Important note: This post is for informational and educational purposes only. This post should not be taken as legal advice or used as a substitute for such. You should always speak to your own legal counsel before taking action.

Gemma Smith

With 7 years in property management, Gemma serves as a key content strategist at Azibo.com. While excelling in writing, editing, and SEO, she also enhances Azibo's social media presence. Passionately, Gemma educates others to make informed real estate investment decisions in the ever-changing market.

Rental rundown background image
Rental rundown hero image

Whether you’re a property owner, renter, property manager, or real estate agent, gain valuable insights, advice, and updates by joining our blog.

Subscriber Identity

I am a

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.